Celine is unhappy about hosting a dating soirée for Luck, but far from detesting the pretty prospects, she finds friendships with each of them. While she fulfills the role of hostess as best she can, she struggles with her broken heart and accepting that a future with Luck isn't possible. Aside from watching Luck grow close with the girls, secrets about Celine's past are unraveled and leave her with more questions. Memories push their way in and leave her mourning the relationships she once had. One significant memory puts Vence Kenbrook in hot water.
Luck isn't sure that he can move on from Celine but takes the opportunity he's given. It's not as easy as he expects, especially with Celine having a front row seat to his dating. He is surprised by the genuine feelings he has for the women he is getting to know. Though his time is mostly taken up with by the girls, Luck helps Celine open doors to her past and he is there for her when memories strike her unexpectedly.
The siblings enjoy teasing Luck about his dating, and relationships begin between unexpected people. After swearing he would never give Anna Hazen the time of day, Sawyer plays cat and mouse with the girl. Beckett is moody and withdrawn and nobody can figure out why. Graham is still waiting with open arms for Claire, but will she ever be ready to move on? His brooding behavior and Celine's melancholy bring them to blows. The young boys have a secret that Luck and Celine are desperate to find out.