Episode 18 is about the true story of the Circleville Letter Writer. From 1976 to 1994, the small town of Circleville, Ohio, was terrorized by a mysterious individual who sent thousands of anonymous, threatening letters to residents. Over the course of 18 years, this person revealed dark secrets, exposed scandals, and instilled fear in the community, forcing people to live in constant anxiety. Who was this elusive writer, and why did they set out to terrorize an entire town?

As we uncover the chilling details of the Circleville Letter Writer case, we’ll explore the complex twists and turns that kept investigators stumped. From accusations of affairs and crimes to strange occurrences like attempted murder, the identity of the Circleville Letter Writer remains one of America’s most unsettling unsolved mysteries. Was this a lone vigilante or someone with personal vendettas? And why did the letters suddenly stop after nearly two decades?

Join hosts John Genua and Jimmy Molloy as they unravel the layers of this terrifying case and discuss theories that continue to baffle experts to this day. Don’t forget to subscribe to America’s Strangest History for more spine-chilling stories, mysterious disappearances, and historical events that defy explanation. Hit the like button if you love a good unsolved mystery, and let us know in the comments if you think you’ve cracked the case of the Circleville Letter Writer!

#circlevilleletters #unsolvedmysteries #circlevilleletters48hours #circlevillelettersdocumentary #mysteriousletters #truecrimepodcast #unsolvedcases #suspensestory #ohioscandal #truecrimedocumentary #ohiotruecrime #circlevillesecrets #circlevillewriteridentity #murdermystery #mysterywriter #smalltownterror #anonymousletters #threateningletters #1976letters #ohiomystery #circlevilleletterwriter