The first Subway Series of 2025 is in the books—and Episode 13 dives straight into the chaos. Alec and Ed unpack the full Juan Soto drama: his cold bat, questionable effort, and the New York crowd that didn’t hold back. Was it fair? Did it finally bring closure for Yankees fans? Then, it’s time to break down the series: who stepped up, who flopped, and what we learned about each squad. Finally, we wrap with a rapid-fire game of Bumpin or Buggin, debating the hottest overreactions from both sides of town.

The Subway Series has arrived, and the city is buzzing. In Episode 12, we set the stage with a full preview of Mets vs. Yankees—starting with a check-in on both squads, key storylines, and stars to watch, including Soto’s first taste of the rivalry. Then it’s time to break down the pitching matchups, bullpens, and offensive firepower before locking in our series predictions and bold takes. We close with a look back at the best Subway Series moments of the past decade, from walk-offs to wild brawls. Queens and the Bronx collide—who takes Round One?

Both New York squads keep stacking wins—Episode 11 recaps a strong week with the Mets and Yankees each taking two series from above-.500 opponents. Alec and Ed break down what’s fueling the charge as the Mets ride reliable starting pitching and health, while the Yankees flex their offensive firepower atop the league in runs scored. With the Subway Series on deck, we tee up the rivalry with a heated off-field debate: which ballpark delivers the better fan experience? From food and vibes to views and value, it’s Citi Field vs. Yankee Stadium in our first-ever Ballpark Breakdown.

Another week of nail-biters in New York—Episode 10 dives into the razor-thin margins both teams are navigating. Alec breaks down the Mets’ continued offensive surge, a bullpen that's starting to bend, and some missed chances with runners in scoring position. Ed covers the Yankees’ homer-heavy approach, bullpen questions around Devin Williams and Mark Leiter Jr., and a stretch of tight games that’s testing their depth. We look at what’s sustainable, what’s not, and where both clubs go from here.

The Mets keep rolling and the Yankees keep battling—Episode 9 breaks down a full week of action. Alec covers the Mets' 7-game stretch against the Phillies and Nationals, highlighting another strong run of pitching and a lineup that’s starting to click. Ed recaps the Yankees' series sets with the Guardians and Blue Jays, where the offense showed flashes but the arms faced some challenges. We break down the trends, the concerns, and who's stepping up for each team.

***Disclaimer: We took Edibles...enjoy.***

The Mets keep surging while the Yankees hold steady—Episode 8 covers another week of highs, concerns, and what’s next. Alec breaks down the Mets’ four-game sweep of the Cardinals, where elite pitching, a rising Soto, and a boost from the supporting cast have Citi Field buzzing. Ed recaps a Yankees series win that came with shaky arms and injury scares, as the offense continues to carry the load. Plus, we spotlight some ex-Mets and ex-Yankees who are thriving elsewhere—and who might’ve made a difference this year in New York.

The Mets keep rolling while the Yankees hit a bump in the road—Episode 7 breaks down the latest from both squads. Alec recaps another strong week for the Mets, who handled the Marlins and A’s behind steady pitching and timely hits. Ed breaks down a rough stretch for the Yankees, who dropped both series and are suddenly facing questions on the mound and at the plate. Plus, we reflect on the legacy of Jackie Robinson and how his impact still echoes through the game today.

The Mets are suddenly sweeping and the Yankees stay the course—Episode 6 breaks it all down. Alec dives into the Mets' strong homestand capped by a sweep of the Jays, where pitching led the way and the bats showed up just enough. Ed recaps the Yankees’ series win in Pittsburgh and questions whether the pitching cracks are cause for concern. Plus, we revisit our Opening Series predictions—were our early takes on track, or just classic overreactions?