Send us a Comment, Question or Request, we'd love to hear from you

Can two sisters who've never met their older siblings somehow remember their lives? On this episode of Bonus Dad, Bonus Daughter, we unravel the eerie tale of the Pollock twins, a story that dances on the edge of reincarnation and family dynamics. We pick apart the threads of nature versus nurture while skeptically examining the possibility of past lives. Could it be parental influence or a cosmic mystery? Our dialogue dives into the comfort people find in these extraordinary beliefs, pondering whether reincarnation is as plausible as it is fascinating—or simply a load of "Pollux."

Media can make or break a story, but does it always tell the truth? We turn a critical eye on the role of sensationalism in high-profile cases like Madeleine McCann's, questioning how headlines can skew reality. Our conversation jumps from modern mysteries to historical enigmas like the Black Dahlia murder, all the way to peculiar urban legends such as the Mothman sightings. Is it a bird, a beast, or just a bump in the night? We even have a lighthearted chuckle over why names like Keith and Nigel have become as rare as a Mothman sighting itself.

Treasures hidden and sounds unheard await as we venture into the lore of the Oak Island Money Pit and the mysterious "Bloop" of the Pacific. From speculations of concealed pirate treasures to the curiosity surrounding enigmatic underwater noises, we examine how archaeologists and scientists strive to unravel these puzzles. Our journey through time and mystery also revisits the Green Children of Woolpit and the ghostly tale of the Mary Celeste, each story leaving seeds of intrigue and wonder. Join us as we weave through these unsolved mysteries, pondering whether some answers are best left to the imagination.

Support the show