Send us a text message for suggestions and feedback or just let us know that you liked the podcast!

What if the most terrifying mysteries aren't hidden in shadowy alleys or abandoned buildings, but instead lurk in plain sight? Join us as we unravel the Gilgo Beach killings, a case that challenges our perception of safety in the everyday world. This episode unfolds the tragic narratives of the "Gilgo Four" and their perilous involvement in the online sex trade, igniting a complex investigation sparked by the search for Shanann Gilbert. The mystery deepens with taunting phone calls and a chilling pattern of crimes centered around Long Island's notorious "box."

We examine the intricate web of technology and anonymity that complicated the investigation, highlighting how platforms like Craigslist enabled both victims and perpetrators to remain hidden. Rex Hoyerman's shocking arrest in 2023 shattered the facade of an ordinary architect when his link to the murders was unveiled through diligent police work. With evidence like DNA matches and incriminating online searches, we discuss the possibility of multiple killers and the haunting idea of more victims dating back to 1993.

The unsettling notion that evil can exist in the most mundane settings pervades this case, prompting us to reflect on Hoyerman's fascination with serial killer psychology. As we navigate this chilling legacy, we emphasize the importance of remembering the victims and supporting their families. This episode challenges us to confront uncomfortable truths about societal vulnerabilities and the urgent need for empathy and vigilance in our pursuit of justice.