In the twentieth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, the team takes a monumental step by securing a sit-down interview with a high-ranking official from the Archdiocese of Baltimore. This two-part interview with the Vice-Chancellor is a pivotal moment in our pursuit of answers. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins engage in a candid and respectful dialogue, confronting the silence that has overshadowed Sister Cathy's story for decades. With sensitivity to survivors of clergy abuse, this episode addresses difficult truths while navigating the corridors of a complex historical case. Join us for this rare encounter as we challenge the church's narrative and strive for clarity in the enduring mystery of Sister Cathy's death.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the fifteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins take a step back from the investigation to reflect on their journey. They share the challenges, experiences, and the weight of responsibility involved in giving a voice to those silenced by Sister Cathy's unsolved murder. This candid episode offers listeners an inside look at the podcasting process behind such a complex true crime story and explores the impact of The Keepers documentary on their lives and the case. Join us as we prepare for the next chapter in our journey for truth, while gathering insights that deepen our understanding of the puzzle that is Sister Cathy's story.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the seventeenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we continue our profound discussion with Ryan White and Jean Wehner, who share unparalleled insights into the lasting impact of The Keepers. Director Ryan White reflects on the documentary's contribution to public awareness and the ongoing challenges of seeking justice. Survivor Jean Wehner bravely details her journey from Jane Doe to a powerful advocate, offering an intimate look at the personal cost of breaking the silence. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins lead this critical dialogue, fostering reflection, understanding, and ongoing advocacy. Join us in unraveling the complex web of deceit and honoring those who dare to seek the truth.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the thirteenth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we sit down with a former student whose connection to Sister Cathy and Sister Russell went beyond the classroom, offering insights into their lives as mentors and friends. Through heartfelt reflections, we explore the personal character and daily lives of these two influential women, shedding light on their passions, concerns, and the human side often lost in the broader true crime narrative. With Gemma Hoskins's insights and Shane Waters's probing questions, this episode provides an intimate glimpse into the lives of Sister Cathy and Sister Russell, enriching our understanding of their legacy and the era they lived in.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the eleventh episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we hear from Charles Franz, who bravely breaks decades of silence about the harrowing abuse he endured at the hands of Father Joseph Maskell. Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins honor Charles' courage as he shares his story—a chilling account of a stolen childhood and the dark reality of trusting those in power. This episode broadens the narrative of Maskell's victims, illuminating the nondiscriminatory nature of his abuses and adding a critical piece to the puzzle of Sister Cathy's case. Join us as we continue to shed light on these stories, honoring the courage it takes to speak out and demanding accountability from those who turned a blind eye.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the seventh episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we explore the courageous legal battles of Jane Roe and Jane Doe as they sought justice against Father Joseph Maskell despite the state's refusal to press criminal charges. Hosts Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins delve into the complexities of the civil lawsuits, highlighting the immense bravery required for survivors to confront both their past abusers and the institutions that protected them. This episode honors the resilience of those who demanded accountability, despite systemic barriers and a culture of silence.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the eighth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we unravel a perplexing layer of the case involving a shadowy figure from the past—Sharon's Uncle Billy. As Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins engage in a compelling dialogue with Sharon Schmidt, they explore the mysterious connection between Uncle Billy and Sister Cathy's death. Was he merely an unnoticed observer, or was there more behind his silent presence at the apartment complex? With Cathy's car abandoned nearby, questions arise that challenge what we thought we knew. This episode invites listeners to question the nature of observation, memory, and the reliability of the people we think we know, as we edge closer to uncovering the truth.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.

In the ninth episode of Who Killed Sister Cathy?, we delve into the enigmatic decisions of Assistant State Attorney Sharon May, exploring her role in the investigation and the controversial choices that have sparked debate for decades. Joined by guest podcaster Brooke Gittings, Shane Waters and Gemma Hoskins unravel the complexities of prosecutorial discretion and the barriers to justice that clouded Sister Cathy's case. Together, they navigate the intersection of law enforcement, power, and accountability, offering listeners a compelling look at the obstacles faced in prosecuting those accused of abuse. This episode provides a thought-provoking examination of justice delayed and the power dynamics at play in Baltimore's most haunting mystery.

Visit itsfoulplay.com to stay engaged in our ongoing investigation.